How to Conduct an HR Compliance Audit

HR compliance audits provide a detailed assessment of your human resources practices that helps you spot any issues, maintain compliance, and stay ahead of the competition. 

With Salary.com's Consulting Services, you can solve your HR auditing problems using efficient data-driven solutions. These tools simplify the process, making it easier to maintain compliance and support a thriving work environment. 

What is an HR compliance audit? 

An HR compliance audit is a thorough review of a company's HR practices, policies, and procedures to ensure they meet all legal and regulatory requirements. This type of audit helps identify any potential compliance issues or risks, making sure the organization adheres to relevant laws and regulations. 

With Salary.com's Consulting Services, you can gain access to HR-reported compensation data to solve your critical auditing challenges; all backed by over 70 years of compensation and total rewards experience. 

What is included in an HR compliance audit? 

A compliance audit looks at many different HR practices, including: 

1. Employment laws and regulations

   Reviewing compliance with federal, state, and local employment laws, such as wage and hour laws and family medical leave regulations. 

2. Documentation and recordkeeping

   Ensuring all HR records, including employment contracts, personnel files, and training records, are complete, accurate, and up to date. 

3. Policies and procedures

   Thorough review of HR policies and procedures to verify they comply with legal requirements and are effectively communicated to employees across all authorities. 

4. Data Privacy and security

   Examine data protection practices to ensure they meet relevant laws, such as GDPR or HIPAA. 

5. Diversity and inclusion

   Evaluating initiatives for diversity and inclusion, including equal pay practices and accommodations for disabilities. 

6. Training and education

   Review the effectiveness of training programs related to compliance, including anti-discrimination, harassment prevention, and workplace safety. 

7. Employee classification

   Ensuring proper classification of employees as exempt or non-exempt, and correctly distinguishing between employees and independent contractors, is an important part of HR audits to prevent legal issues. 

Demographic Data Audit can help your organization find inconsistencies, inaccuracies, and opportunities in employee demographic data. 

When to conduct an HR compliance audit?

It's important to know when to conduct an HR audit. Here are some key scenarios that should prompt an audit: 

Regular audits 

Many organizations conduct periodic compliance audits, typically annually or biannually, to proactively address potential compliance issues and mitigate risks. 

Mergers and acquisitions 

Conduct an audit when undergoing mergers, acquisitions, or structural changes to ensure HR practices are consistent with new organizational requirements. 

To help ease the transition period, Life Cycle Audits provide HR technology strategies to stay ahead of the next change that comes along.  

Regulatory changes 

When substantial changes in employment laws or regulations occur, an HR audit can help ensure that HR practices remain compliant with the latest legal and regulatory requirements. 

Employee complaints or legal actions 

If faced with employee complaints, legal disputes, or audits by regulatory bodies, conducting an audit is crucial to address concerns and prepare for potential legal challenges. 

New HR initiatives 

Implementing new HR initiatives or policies needs an HR audit to ensure they align with the organization's legal and regulatory compliance requirements. 

Why are HR compliance audits important? 

The primary objective of an HR audit is to ensure legal compliance and minimize liabilities to promote a fair and respectful workplace. Keeping the organization's HR policies and procedures up to date ensures that businesses can reduce regulatory violations and support employee satisfaction and retention.

Benefits of HR compliance audits 

Here are some reasons why compliance audits are important for companies and employees alike:  

• Identify potential risks: Compliance audits help uncover potential risks related to labor laws and internal guidelines, ensuring your organization adheres to current laws and regulations. 

• Ensure legal compliance: Helps verify that your HR department’s policies and practices align with legal requirements which protects your organization from non-compliance issues. 

• Improve workplace safety: Assesses workplace safety measures and employee benefits to create a safer and more supportive environment for all employees. 

• Enhance employee engagement: Regular compliance audits review job descriptions, performance management practices, and employee handbook content, which can boost employee engagement and retention. 

• Strengthen HR policies: An HR audit process evaluates your HR department’s procedures and documentation to help refine policies for fair compensation, equal employment opportunities, and effective HR functions. 

To help with this process, HR Metrics & Analytics will review your current HR metrics, establish benchmarks and provide a model for measuring effectiveness over time. 

The challenges of HR compliance auditing 

The auditing process comes with a set of challenges that can make it complex and demanding, such as: 

Keeping up with changing laws and regulations 

Ensuring compliance with constantly evolving local laws and regulations can overwhelm the HR department and complicate the compliance audit process. 

If you have pay equity challenges for example, Pay Equity Audit and Certification Consulting will assess differences in pay and determine if they are justified under the law.  

Organizing required documentation 

Collecting comprehensive and accurate documentation, like job descriptions and performance management records, is crucial but often challenging during an audit. 

Balancing HR policies with business goals 

Balancing the need for strict adherence to HR policies with the organization’s business goals can be tough for compliance auditors, especially when adapting to new employees and procedures. 

How to conduct an HR compliance audit 

A proactive approach can lead to better HR function and a competitive advantage for your organization. Here are six simple steps to conduct your own HR compliance audit: 

1. Step 1: Define the scope and objectives

   Clarify the scope of your HR auditing. A compliance auditor should identify the specific HR functions and legal requirements to review, such as equal employment opportunity and disability accommodations, so your audit focuses on essential functions and local laws. 

2. Step 2: Gather relevant documentation

   Collect all necessary documents related to HR policies, employee records, and compliance reports. This includes hiring practices, non-exempt employees' records, and written reports to ensure compliance with your organization's policies and local laws. 

3. Step 3: Conduct initial interviews

   Meet with HR departments, hiring managers, and legal counsel to understand current practices and identify potential areas of non-compliance. This step helps you gauge whether HR functions align with both the organization’s policies and legal requirements. 

4. Step 4: Perform the audit

   Review documentation and conduct mini audits of key HR processes, including employee retention strategies and the handling of disability accommodations. Ensure that HR practices comply with legal standards and internal policies. 

5. Step 5: Analyze findings and identify issues

   Evaluate your findings to determine any instances of non-compliance or gaps in HR practices. Your audit report should highlight these issues and provide recommendations for improvement. This helps the organization understand where changes are needed. 

6. Step 6: Develop an action plan and follow-up

   Create a detailed action plan based on your audit report to address any identified issues. Ensure that your plan includes timelines and responsibilities for implementing changes, and schedule follow-up audits to monitor progress and ensure ongoing compliance. 

HR compliance audits ensure that your business practices are both legal and effective. This proactive approach can help identify potential legal issues and areas for improvement, helping organizations stay compliant and competitive. Salary.com's Consulting Services can help your organization solve your human resources auditing problems using data-driven solutions.